Criminal Defense Attorney
Marchman Act Defense
Lawyer in Orlando, FL
Contesting Involuntary Substance Abuse Petitions and Protecting Your Rights
✓ Emergency Response 24/7
✓ Contested Assessment Hearings
✓ Treatment Petition Defense
✓ Confidentiality Protection
✓ Payment Plans Available
Marchman Act Defense Attorneys Orlando, FL
Defending Against a Marchman Act Petition
The Marchman Act — the Hal S. Marchman Alcohol and Other Drug Services Act, § 397 — lets families, doctors, and police petition Florida courts to compel involuntary substance abuse assessment and treatment. When you are the respondent, the case moves fast: a petition for assessment is heard within 10 days, and a follow-up petition for treatment can result in up to 90 days of court-ordered inpatient or outpatient care, with renewals available. A Marchman order can strip driving privileges, trigger firearm consequences, and appear in family court disputes. Smith & Eulo represents respondents at every stage — challenging the petition, cross-examining the qualified professional, presenting alternative plans, and pursuing appeals. We move quickly and treat every case with discretion.
How a Marchman Case Moves
1. Petition Filed
Family, physician, or law enforcement files a Petition for Involuntary Assessment under § 397.6811
2. Ex Parte Order
The court may enter an ex parte order for law enforcement to take the respondent into custody
3. Assessment Hearing
Court holds a hearing within 10 days; if granted, respondent is assessed for up to 5 days
4. Treatment Petition
Petitioner may file a separate Petition for Involuntary Treatment after assessment
5. Treatment Hearing
Hearing within 10 days on whether to order up to 90 days of treatment
6. Renewal or Discharge
Court may renew treatment orders in 90-day increments or discharge the respondent
How We Defend Marchman Petitions
Marchman defense is fast, technical, and evidence-driven:
Petition Sufficiency
The petition must satisfy every element of § 397.6811 — procedural defects can end the case.
Cross-Examining the QP
We challenge the qualified professional’s methodology, criteria findings, and treatment recommendations.
Independent Evaluation
A privately retained addiction professional can rebut the assessment and show voluntary treatment is appropriate.
Voluntary Treatment Alternative
Presenting a concrete voluntary plan often persuades the court to deny involuntary orders.
Family Motive Cross
When a Marchman is filed amid divorce or custody disputes, we expose ulterior motives.
Appeals
Marchman orders can be appealed to the district court of appeal within 30 days.
Marchman Criteria Under Florida Law
Three-Prong Test (§ 397.675)
A person must (1) have lost the power of self-control with respect to substance use, AND (2) either be likely to inflict physical harm on self or others or be in need of substance abuse services and be incapable of appreciating that need.
Standard of Proof
Clear and convincing evidence — the petitioner bears this burden at every hearing.
Assessment Period
An assessment order allows detention for up to 5 days at a licensed facility.
Treatment Period
A treatment order authorizes up to 90 days, renewable in 90-day increments.
Least Restrictive Alternative
Courts must consider outpatient or less-restrictive options before inpatient placement.
Marchman Act Defense Matters We Handle
We represent respondents in every type of Marchman Act matter:
- Involuntary Assessment Petitions – Contesting the initial 5-day assessment order
- Involuntary Treatment Petitions – Fighting 60- and 90-day treatment orders
- Ex Parte Pickup Orders – Challenging law enforcement custody orders
- Extension Petitions – Opposing 90-day treatment renewals
- Contempt Proceedings – Defending alleged violations of Marchman treatment orders
- Marchman Appeals – Appellate review of assessment and treatment orders
- Baker Act & Marchman Overlap – Coordinated defense when both are invoked
- Family-Court-Driven Petitions – Cases filed during divorce or custody disputes
- Employer or Physician Petitions – Professional licensing consequences and PRN cases
- Confidentiality Enforcement – Enforcing 42 CFR Part 2 and Florida confidentiality provisions
Your Rights During Marchman Proceedings
Right to Counsel
You have the right to an attorney at every hearing — privately retained or court-appointed.
Right to Notice
You must be personally served with the petition and receive notice of the hearing.
Right to Present Evidence
You can present witnesses, cross-examine the petitioner, and introduce medical records.
Right to Confidentiality
Marchman proceedings and treatment records are confidential under Florida law and 42 CFR Part 2.
Right to Appeal
Any Marchman order can be appealed within 30 days to the district court of appeal.
Collateral Consequences
Firearms: A Marchman treatment adjudication can trigger firearm restrictions in some circumstances.
Driver’s License: Orders may result in DHSMV notice and license restrictions in DUI-adjacent cases.
Professional Licenses: Doctors, nurses, pilots, and attorneys face reporting to PRN, IPN, and licensing boards.
Custody Matters: Marchman history is frequently raised in family court timesharing disputes.
Employment & Insurance: Treatment costs and disclosure risks can be significant.
Frequently Asked Questions
Call a Marchman Act defense attorney immediately. The assessment hearing is held within 10 days of the petition, and preparation makes the difference. Do not speak to the petitioning family member’s attorney or make admissions to any evaluator without counsel present.
Yes. The Marchman Act allows the court to issue an ex parte order directing law enforcement to take the respondent into custody for delivery to the assessment facility. Being picked up does not mean you have been found to meet the criteria — that determination comes at the hearing.
Under § 397.6811, a spouse, guardian, relative, private practitioner, director of a licensed service provider, or any three adults with personal knowledge may file. Law enforcement can also initiate emergency protective custody in specific circumstances.
Yes. Marchman orders are appealable to the district court of appeal within 30 days of the order. We handle Marchman appellate practice throughout Florida’s DCAs and can move for stays where appropriate.
Florida Marchman Act Laws
Florida Statute Chapter 397
The Hal S. Marchman Alcohol and Other Drug Services Act.
§ 397.675 — Criteria
Establishes the substantive criteria for involuntary assessment and treatment.
§ 397.6811 — Petition for Assessment
Governs who may petition, what the petition must allege, and how it is heard.
§ 397.6957 — Involuntary Treatment
Governs petitions and orders for up to 90 days of court-ordered treatment.
42 CFR Part 2
Federal confidentiality rules for substance abuse treatment records — stricter than HIPAA.
Counties We Serve
Orange County
Orlando, Winter Park, and surrounding areas.
Seminole County
Sanford, Altamonte Springs, Lake Mary.
Osceola County
Kissimmee and Osceola County courts.
Hillsborough County
Tampa and Tampa Bay area courts.
Brevard County
Melbourne, Cocoa, and Space Coast.
Statewide
Representation across all Florida judicial circuits.
Meet Your Marchman Defense Team
Criminal Defense Attorney
Criminal Defense Attorney
Criminal Defense Attorney
Immigration Lawyer
Managing Partner
Founding Partner
Managing Partner
Managing Partner
Managing Partner
Family Law Attorney
Senior Attorney
Senior Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Defense Attorney
Attorney
What Our Clients Say
Why Choose Smith & Eulo?
Emergency Response – Marchman hearings are on 10-day tracks — we move immediately
Respondent-Side Focus – We defend respondents; we know the petition playbook
Expert Networks – Access to addiction professionals for independent evaluations
Appellate Practice – We take Marchman orders up when the record supports it
Discretion – Sensitive representation for high-profile and professional-license clients
Case Results
Assessment Denied – Court refused to enter involuntary assessment after contested hearing
Treatment Petition Withdrawn – Voluntary treatment plan persuaded petitioner to withdraw
Outpatient Ordered – Judge rejected inpatient treatment in favor of outpatient plan
Renewal Denied – Successful opposition to 90-day extension
Appeal Reversed – DCA vacated treatment order for insufficient evidence
Consequences Beyond Treatment
Custody & Family Court: Marchman orders are commonly cited in timesharing decisions.
Professional Licenses: Physicians, nurses, and attorneys risk PRN/IPN referral and board discipline.
Employment & Clearances: Employers with drug-free workplace policies may act on treatment orders.
Insurance: Treatment costs and privacy protections need to be evaluated case-by-case.
Firearms: Involuntary commitment findings can affect firearm eligibility in some cases.
Related Practice Areas
Marchman matters often intersect with these areas of our practice:
Baker Act Defense – Involuntary mental health commitments
Drug Crimes – Related criminal charges involving substances
DUI Defense – When Marchman intersects with DUI cases
Professional License Defense – PRN, IPN, and board discipline
Family & Custody Matters – Coordinated defense with family counsel
Complete Marchman Defense FAQ
The Baker Act addresses involuntary mental health examination and placement. The Marchman Act addresses involuntary substance abuse assessment and treatment. Both can be invoked at the same time. We defend respondents in both types of proceedings.
An assessment order authorizes up to 5 days at the assessment facility. A treatment order authorizes up to 90 days, renewable in 90-day increments upon a new petition and hearing. Every renewal is a separate opportunity to oppose continued involuntary treatment.
Clear and convincing evidence — higher than a preponderance but lower than beyond a reasonable doubt. The petitioner must prove every element of § 397.675 at every hearing. Insufficient evidence is a common reversal ground on appeal.
Yes — the least restrictive alternative principle allows the court to order outpatient treatment or accept a voluntary treatment plan in lieu of involuntary inpatient placement. Presenting a concrete voluntary alternative is often the most effective defense strategy.
Yes. Substance use disorder records are protected by 42 CFR Part 2, a federal confidentiality rule stricter than HIPAA, and by Florida law. Marchman proceedings themselves are confidential. Improper disclosures can be challenged.
Yes. Physicians and nurses face PRN and IPN referrals; attorneys face FLA Lawyer Assistance and bar discipline; pilots face FAA reporting. Board-related consequences often outweigh the treatment order itself — which is why fighting the petition matters.
You can be held in contempt, returned to inpatient treatment, or subject to further orders. We defend contempt proceedings and move to modify orders that are impractical to comply with.
Yes. Family courts routinely consider Marchman petitions and orders in timesharing decisions despite the confidentiality statute. We coordinate with family law counsel to limit improper use and to prepare rebuttal evidence.
Yes. Marchman orders are appealable to the district court of appeal within 30 days. We routinely handle Marchman appeals and can move for a stay of the treatment order pending appeal in appropriate cases.
Fees depend on the stage — assessment hearing, treatment hearing, renewal, or appeal. Smith & Eulo offers free consultations and flat-fee options for most Marchman matters, and payment plans are available.
Contact Us Today For Your Free Consultation
If a Marchman petition has been filed against you or a loved one, call us right away. Available 24/7, free consultation, and payment plans available.
What To Do Right Now
Note the hearing date. Assessment and treatment hearings are within 10 days — the calendar drives everything.
Preserve records. Save prior treatment records, medical documentation, and voluntary care plans.
Do not admit to evaluators without counsel. Statements made during assessment are used at the treatment hearing.
Line up a voluntary plan. A concrete outpatient or voluntary treatment plan is the strongest defense at hearing.
Call us immediately. Every day inside the 10-day window matters.
Related Resources
Baker Act Defense – Involuntary mental health commitments
42 CFR Part 2 – Federal confidentiality for treatment records
Professional License Discipline – PRN, IPN, and board consequences
Marchman & Family Court – Timesharing and custody impact
Marchman Appeals – Reviewing and overturning orders
